Like everything with pointed pen calligraphy — particularly modern calligraphy — your ink choice comes down to a number of various factors. You need to consider:

the paper you're writing on
your personal style of writing
the quality of the ink

As a newbie to calligraphy, I have a lot to learn, and I found a really comprehensive review about inks over at The Calligraphy Pen that's worth a read. My approach here is by no means scientific, but I hope gives you an idea of the different kinds of inks that are available for you to try out yourself. I'd love to hear your experiences and favourites.

My favourite calligraphy inks

In doing this exercise, I've narrowed down my favourites (for now. It changes as I go):

Speedball. It's one smooth criminal
Winsor & Newton (calligraphy ink)
Daler Rowney Calli
Gouache mixes
Pelikan 4001 (a good practice workhorse)

The paper I've used

Different papers will take ink differently. Some will bleed, some will catch, and some will be so smooth you won't want to stop writing. I'm still in the process of investigating paper variants, so for this exercise, I've used:

my practice paper: HP Colour Laser Paper 100gsm
Artcoe Frisk black pad 135gsm (not particular smooth).

You'll see that two inks in particular didn't sit so well on the laser paper (Higgins [non-waterproof] Sepia and W&N Nut Brown). I'll review how they sit on vellum (Rhodia) paper soon. The review I linked to earlier highlights that the Higgins Eternal is a better option for calligraphy.

The inks I've used

I've used the variety of calligraphy and drawing inks I've collected over the last six months. I go into more detail about them beneath the images, including where you can buy them online*, and my experience in general (if worth noting) with them on this type of paper.

In general, I wouldn't recommend using the W&N drawing inks (use the calligraphy inks instead) as they don't have the pigment that you need. And please excuse that I've spelt "Winsor" and "Pelikan" wrong in my examples... duh.

*Note: where I've linked to a product, an italicisedlink indicates that I haven't had experience ordering from that company yet.

Black, brown and metallic ink

Speedball and Windsor & Newton metallics

Ink

Colour

Type

Where to buy

Pelikan 4001

Brilliant Black

Fountain Pen Ink (non-waterproof)

,

,

,

Speedball

Superblack India Ink

Waterproof

,

,

,

Winsor & Newton

951 Black Indian Ink

Permanent

Blots Pen & Inks

,

Cass Art

,

Jackson's

Higgins

Sepia

Non-waterproof

Try Higgins Eternal instead

Amazon.co.uk

,

Scribblers

,

Blots & Pens

Winsor & Newton

Nut Brown

Water resistant drawing ink

Cass Art

,

Blots Pen & Inks

Speedball

Gold

Super pigmented acrylic

Blots Pen & Inks

Winsor & Newton

Gold

Water resistant drawing ink

Amazon.co.uk

,

Cornellisen

,

Jackson's

Winsor & Newton

Silver

Calligraphy ink (non-waterproof)

,

,

,

The Higgins and W&N nut brown inks are definitely not friends with the quality of paper I was using. They are better on Rhodia (vellum) paper, but I think there are better alternatives from the same brands.

Although I prefer the finish of the W&N gold better than the Speedball gold, it's just too hard to write with. The fine hairline upstrokes are virtually impossible to make smoothly.

Blue, purple and green ink

W&N violet and green, Schmincke gouache mix

Ink

Colour

Type

Where to buy

Speedball

Blue

Super pigmented acrylic

Blots Pen & Inks

Daler Rowney

Blue

Waterproof

Amazon.co.uk

,

Blots Pen & Inks

,

Turners

Winsor & Newton

Violet

Non-waterproof

Jackson's

,

Cornellisen's

,

Blots Pen & Ink

Winsor & Newton

Green

Non-waterproof

Jackson's

,

Cornellisen's

,

Blots Pen & Ink

Schmincke

helio green bluish & white

Gouache (Horadam)

,

,

,

I've just learnt that a Schmincke 'calligraphy' gouache is available. I do find the one I'm using to be a little scratchy, so it would be interesting to see if the calligraphy version is smoother.